the court has ruled
Nico is better than Percy
judge Lady Justice · Scales in one hand, receipts in the other.
RECEIPTS
The People's Court of Petty Disputes
NO. WZ4ZUH2026-10-29 14:04
JUDGE: LADY JUSTICEROUND 1/3
Nico is better than Percy
Undead or Underrated? The Trial of Two Demigods
ItemPts
PLNTTrauma Depth+10
Nico's darkness gives him Shakespearean complexity Percy lacks
PLNTTartarus Survival+12
Not just survived but comprehended the abyss itself
PLNTPower Uniqueness+8
Skeleton manipulation > water control in sheer fright factor
DFNDMain Character Privilege+5
Narrative importance ≠ character depth
DFNDPower Versatility+7
Sea powers offer more creative applications than necromancy
PLNTCharacter Arc+9
From bitter outcast to redeemed leader - Percy's growth is linear
PLNT SUBTOTAL+39
DFND SUBTOTAL+12
VERDICTANONYMOUS WINS
Certainty75%
“The scales of judgment tip toward the son of Hades, whose darkness has forged a character as complex as the Underworld itself. Percy may command the seas, but Nico commands the shadows of our souls.”
— Lady Justice
*WZ4ZUH*
Thank you for filing — please appeal responsibly
receipts · no lawyers were harmed
receipts · no lawyers were harmed
PAID IN FULL
The roast
In this battle of mythological might, Percy's claim washed away like a sandcastle at high tide.
What would've won it
For your appeal, compare Percy's water powers to Nico's shadow manipulation in terms of tactical versatility - Percy's powers bend to his will, but Nico's bend reality itself.
Strengths & fallacies
- + Deep psychological complexity
- + Survived literal hell
- + Central narrative position
- + More versatile elemental powers
- − Appeal to Popularity: “Percy only gets stated as 'better'…”
appeals send a fresh link — pass it back or email it straight away